Blog · Essay

What the Willow Creek study got right, and the dashboard we refuse to build

Published November 10, 2026

Key points

  • What REVEAL found and what its critics said
  • Why a measure becomes a target and stops measuring
  • The one rule in our design that follows from it

In 2007 Willow Creek Community Church published the results of a survey of its own people and then of several hundred other congregations. The study was called REVEAL, and its headline finding was uncomfortable for a church that had spent three decades building programs: participation in church activities didn't predict spiritual growth. People who attended more, served more and joined more groups were not, on that account, closer to Christ. What did track with growth was personal practice, Scripture read alone, prayer, and close relationships. Bill Hybels said in public that the church had made a mistake and would change.

The study's authors described a continuum of four stages, from exploring Christianity, through growing in Christ and close to Christ, to Christ-centered. The most important segment they found wasn't at either end. It was a group of mature believers who were stalled, and a smaller group who were dissatisfied with the church's role in their growth and thinking about leaving.

What the critics said

REVEAL deserves its critics, and we read them. The sociologist Bradley Wright pointed out that it was a single snapshot, that a self-report survey of how close people feel to God isn't a measure of growth over time, and that some of its conclusions went further than its data. The four stages are labels people chose for themselves on one day, not a ladder anyone climbed under observation. We treat the continuum as a useful shape and not as a law.

But the central finding has held up in every honest conversation we have had with a pastor since. Attendance is easy to count and tells you almost nothing about whether a person is becoming like Jesus. Everyone who has sat in a church office knows a faithful attender who hasn't changed in twenty years, and a person who vanished from the rota for a season because they were quietly carrying a dying parent, which was the most formative thing that ever happened to them.

Goodhart's law comes to church

There is a rule in economics, usually called Goodhart's law, that when a measure becomes a target it stops being a good measure. Dashboards do this to churches. Once "people in groups" is a number on a screen, the number gets pushed up, and the groups get larger and shallower, and the number keeps rising while the thing it was supposed to stand for declines. The same is true of every count we could show a person: days read, weeks attended, steps completed. Show it and you have told them what to optimize, and they will optimize it, and it was never the point.

This is why we were uneasy with our own first draft. The first version of our design recorded "markers": a person read this, attended that, finished the other. It was a competent spec for tracking activity. It was the dashboard REVEAL warned us about.

The rule that follows

So the design now has one rule above the others: nothing shown to a person is a number. No streaks, no bars, no percentages, no stage labels on their own page. Progress, where it is shown at all, is told as a story in sentences with dates: since Advent you started reading Mark with Sam, you kept Sunday evenings for the examen most weeks, you were baptised on the twelfth. Counts exist for shepherds, and even for them they come second on the page, after names. In the first release there are none for a person at all, and the pastor's weekly email says in sentences who said yes, whose season ends soon, whose questions have stopped and who has no one walking with them yet.

And the only honest measure of formation is the one REVEAL reached for and couldn't quite hold: qualitative, over time, in the person's own words. The fruit of the Spirit isn't a count. So the design asks, in a later step and only in a church that wants it, once a season and only if the person wants it, a short reflection on love, joy, peace, patience and the rest, answered privately, with the option of a discipler answering the same question about them, compared only between the two of them. A church sees how many people answered and nothing else, unless someone chooses to share.

If that sounds like a system that is hard to put on a slide, it is. It is also the only kind we think is worth building.

Next week: why the size of a group is a theological decision, and what a band of five does that a class of twelve can't.

In EmmauOS now

The rule held through every slice. A person's own page has no number on it. The pastor's Map shows people by name, and draws the people with nobody walking with them as outlines, so the gaps appear as people rather than as a number. Its Movement table counts the last 12 months, and any count under three reads "fewer than 3", so the table can never point at one person. Diagnostics write fixed sentences from counts and dates. None of them names anyone.

The Map: a column for each stage, a filled dot for someone walked with, a ring for someone who walks with another, and the Movement table beneath.
What EmmauOS keeps, who can see it, and what it never holds.
What EmmauOS keeps, who can see it, and what it never holds.

The Map and Diagnostics explain each part.

Sources

  • Hawkins, G. and Parkinson, C., Reveal: Where Are You? (2007) and Follow Me (2008), Willow Creek Association. Modern Reformation's review of both.
  • "Willow Creek Repents?", Christianity Today, October 2007. Article.
  • Wright, B., "A Sociologist Reviews Willow Creek's REVEAL Study", 2007. Reposted at rayfowler.org.
  • Goodhart, C., "Problems of Monetary Management: The U.K. Experience" (1975); the popular form is Marilyn Strathern's, "when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure", European Review 5 (1997).
  • Galatians 5:22–23.